A Philosophy of Marketing

User login

So an author friend of mine has run into a spot of bother with her pregnancy (my wife did too, it's very distressing, though all was, and will be, well). Her book, her first, is publishing at the end of this month, and I've been helping her with promotion.

In so doing I got in a lovely email exchange with an librarian who remembered me from my Soft Skull days because of my rather vived marketing approach. I thanked her although I felt a wee twinge of weirdness. Is that what/who I am? I'm reminded of Bill Hicks's famous rant about marketers: "Anyone here in marketing? Kill yourself. Seriously, though. If you are, do. Really. There's no rationalization for what you do and you are Satan's little helpers."

Now, given that I helped market Bill Hick's book Love All The People, I feel like I can give myself a shot at rationalizing what I do.

The Industrial Revolution make the cultural nexus called "book" into a product to be sold in a supply chain like a shoe or a chair.

The supply chain is now dramatically shrunk even as more product is being pushed into it.

So the book is now something more of your self, something you exchange with others more like a talk, a conversation, a class, an event than like a lampshade or a hammer.

Which entails, quite fundamentally, that others do not really sell it for you; it is you, so you do the selling.

We've a tendency to see this as bad, but I think it is healthy and more integrated. To create a product for others to do all the selling involves an awful lot of good ole Marxist alienation. Of course, to do all the selling can be emotionally very taxing but that's true of many activities.

Don't get me wrong, I love what I do, I'd be despondent if I no longer had a role in helping writers and readers connect. (That might make me kill myself!) But I do realize that the only truly organic way to do it, the only honest and authentic way to do it, is for the writer to do it. So, writers, feel no shame in hustling. It may well be the Edenic state.

Comments

As I've read everyone's comments, my thoughts have gone to my own reading habits -- the books and authors I love. How did I learn about them? Mostly through reading. Like seems to spawn like, so reading one author leads me to another, which leads me to another. Certain authors resonate with me, my attitudes and beliefs. I'm not being glib or saying "write great content", if anything you should try and write authentic content and learn to hone your writing voice. As a writer, once you can reach those readers who resonate with you, they can hear your authorial voice and that will be the best marketing you can do. Unfortunately, this is a slow, slow process, but getting your words out there is a necessary first step. Which brings me to this site, yet another platform to be heard on and to search for that elusive author-reader connection. If it does nothing else, it will provide some authors the marketing opportunity to reach a new group of readers. As it stands, I've already bought one book, Lynne Tillman's from my experience with Red Lemonade. I'm sure I'll buy more as time goes on. In the end, marketing is more a matter of taste and class. Great marketing will reflect the writer's resonant frequency and be heard by the readers who are interested in that author's works.
A writer I've seen do this really well is Jonathan Evison. He seems to appear everywhere & always presents himself with kindness & humility. With Jonathan, I don't see self-promotion as much as someone who just enjoys people. He builds up such goodwill toward his work that he builds on his successes, while maintaining the freedom to write the kind of books he wants to write.
. . .nice of you to notice, richard, and kind of you to say so! . . . the truth is, i don't feel like i'm promoting, so much as just representing and accounting for my narratives . . . speaking to a group of readers is one of my most instructive exercises, and welcomed opportunities as a writer . . . i feel like bouncing off my readers is a continuation of the conversation which the narrative was designed to spark in the first place . . . otherwise, i'm just talking at people . . . i learn things about my own books, my own skill-sets. my own shortcomings . . . and really, is there anybody else out there more qualified to represent your work than, well, you? . . . the bottom line, for me, is this: stories are collaborative--the writer is only one part of the equation . . . i can blast the world with radio waves, but without receivers they're useless . . . writing is bad when it doesn't respect the reader enough . . .
The more and more I do in terms of opening myself to audiences, the more clear it becomes to me that marketing books, when you are the writer of said books, has to be about sharing -- sharing the work, sharing your ideas, sharing your access. So, this platform is really really smart IMO. Kathryn
Kathryn FTW! Sharing for sure and let's not forget connecting. No other "content delivery system" provide such a powerful insight into individuals you meet. Books provide a common starting ground of works and authors to explore new worlds (personal, spiritual, geographic and theoretical) with new associates and old friends.
Sure, and if the general, universal impetus is giving, then the information/story flows purely. The idea of withholding help or ideas or useful criticism or resources strikes me as a sure way to a bitter self. Better to put yourself in service to the word and keep that moving. Step toward it and dance toward it. And bring everyone you can along. You get one life. &etc.
...I'd promote this. Hee, hee! Yeah, that's what we believe, but hearing it from writers directly, that feels really really really good...
I never thought I'd see the day that I'd be muddling my way through marketing...let's just say, I'm not a real 'go-getter', I'd rather be writing, editing, revising and daydreaming out the window than doing marketing...I always hoped in my little daydreams that someone else would be doing that for me...I always thought I'd have a lot of things being done for me, but... So I've been taking baby steps. It's certainly easier peddling books over the internet. I'm still muddling along doing POD paperback originals and so far making ebooks available for the NOOK...yes, just baby steps, little ones and then big ones. I use self-serve advertising through websites like Goodreads.com, hold Q&A chats at sites like Library Thing (usually met with "crickets", so I wind up talking to myself and leaving paragraphs of back story about the book and "readings" of samples from chapters, the chats are archived so if anyone happens to be looking they can find.) I also do giveaways in exchange for reviews, weekly blogging, and local book signings and readings, all very low key and low budget (except shipping a book to Austrailia for a giveaway winner cost more than the book is worth! But I did get a nice review! Priceless!!) And I make myself approachable. In spite of my cautious little baby steps, my books are selling and being read by readers, and I've talked to many of them about their experience (I love it when they come to me and say my book made them cry! They do get a hug if I'm physically in the same room with them.) So far so good, for something that started out as an experiment, learning as I go, I can't complain too much, the investment has been worth it. I might not be a slick marketing wunderkind, but I am getting my books into the hands of readers...and on their NOOKS. It's a little exciting, but I don't let myself get too excited. It is a labor of love...the writer is the best advocate for their work and their vision, it's the way to do it.
That is a very gentle and wise response. Honestly slick marketing wunderkinds have always failed in this business. The original PR flack, Edward Bernays, was hired by the publishing industry in the early 1930s and he foundered. His two schemes were to try to coin a phrase with the moral opprobrium of "scofflaw" to describe someone who borrowed books, whether from a library or a friend. The second was to persuade interior designers to install more bookshelves so as to increase demand for products to fill them. You can imagine how sustainable that approach was...
I agree that these days the writer is ultimately the person responsible for getting the book to his or her audience; however, from what I've seen the past few years from the retail side, writers aren't ashamed of hustling. As a buyer I've received more advanced copies directly from authors and met with more authors (self-published and not) than I can count. What writers are is naive about marketing. I've met writers who couldn't properly define the term. Too many writers put too much effort into marketing without any proper plan.

Though I do think that anyone who wants to make money off of a product should understand the fundamentals of marketing, it's hard to expect writers who spend all their time trying to be experts in their fields to commit all of their time to a successful marketing campaign. So in addition to your assuagement to feel no shame in hustling, I would add, feel no shame in hiring some kind of marketing consultant or at least hiring a good publicist who knows the industry.
Agreed! What I've found is that people sometimes hop to it without a strategy and then burnout ... We are idea people so ideas aren't the trouble, it's staying on a clear path that is manageable (or at least for me!) ... Strategy allows me to stay on track by asking the question, "Will this new idea how to promote/reach folks get me closer to a specific goal or am I shooting bullets?"... Marketing burnout can be the longest flu you've ever had. . .
Agreed, yes. Though I would emphasize someone who emphasizes teaching you to fish, rather than promising you salmon poached in butter for dinner.